Best Pizza in Paducah
Updated October 2026 · 8 places · Paducah
These eight currently operating Paducah, Kentucky, pizza spots include independent pizzerias and local restaurants known for serving pizza. The list puts locally rooted options first and includes Pizza Inn as a long-running local outpost; it excludes national chains without a clear local distinction.
Map coming soon
Our Picks
Pizza By The Pound
600 N 32nd St, Paducah, KY 42001
Pizza By The Pound is a family-owned Paducah restaurant that has served the area since 1990. Reviews mention its specialty pizzas, retro memorabilia-filled setting, and unusual eight-pound pizza challenge.
Michael’s New York Style Pizza
901 Kentucky Ave, Paducah, KY 42003
Michael’s New York Style Pizza is a locally listed pizzeria on Kentucky Avenue. Reviewers highlight its New York-style pizza, including handmade dough and the flavor of its sauce, cheese, and toppings.
J. Bella’s Pizzeria
2406 New Holt Rd, Paducah, KY 42001
J. Bella’s is a Paducah pizzeria whose own site describes its focus as thin-crust pizza made with handmade dough. Reviewers mention the crisp crust and specialty pies such as the Kitchen Sink and Meat Lovers.
Max’s Brick Oven Cafe
112 Market House Sq, Paducah, KY 42001
Max’s Brick Oven Cafe is a downtown restaurant serving Italian and American dishes, including brick-oven pizza. Reviews describe its pizzas as thin and crisp, and mention Italian sausage among the toppings.
Paducah Beer Werks
301 N 4th St, Paducah, KY 42001
Paducah Beer Werks is a brewpub that serves pizza alongside beer and other pub food. Reviewers mention its brick-oven pizza and praise the crust and flavor of particular pies.
Italian Village Pizza
125 S 3rd St, Paducah, KY 42001
Italian Village Pizza is a casual pizzeria serving pizza and other Italian-American fare in downtown Paducah. Reviewers call out its cracker-like crust and cheese-to-sauce balance.
Pizza Warehouse
451 Jordan Dr, Suite A, Paducah, KY 42001
Pizza Warehouse is a pizza restaurant on Jordan Drive. It appears among Paducah’s reviewed pizza spots, though available reviews are mixed about the food.
Pizza Inn
1001 Joe Clifton Dr, Paducah, KY 42001
Pizza Inn is a Paducah pizza restaurant that advertises a broad selection of pizza, pasta, salad, and dessert pizza. Its listing says the location has served the area since 1972, and reviewers mention the variety and friendly staff.